[ Pdf The Somme: The Darkest Hour on the Western Front ↠´ european-history PDF ] by Peter Hart ¼ myportal.pro

[ Pdf The Somme: The Darkest Hour on the Western Front ↠´ european-history PDF ] by Peter Hart ¼ On July The British Army Launched The Big Push That Was Supposed To Bring An End To The Horrific Stalemate On The Western Front Between British, French And German Forces What Resulted Was One Of The Greatest Single Human Catastrophes In Twentieth Century Warfare Scrambling Out Of Trenches In The Face Of German Machine Guns And Artillery Fire, The British Lost Over Twenty Thousand Soldiers During The First Day This Battle Would Drag On For Another Four Bloody MonthsExpertly Weaving Together Letters, Diaries, And Other First Person Accounts, Peter Hart Gives Us A Compelling Narrative Tribute To This Infamous Tragedy That Epitomized The Futility Of The War To End All Wars An oral history of the Battle of the Somme A brutal look at one of the grueling battles of World War 1 The British lost 57,000 soldiers at the opening of the battle It is a really interesting first hand accounting of what the Trench Warfare was like in the first world war A well written, insightful and detailed history of the Battle of the Somme The Battle of the Somme has become one of the most common ways to illustrate the horror and apparent futility of the First World War The overall context of the Great War has long been forgotten and the teaching of the subject reduced to an adjunct of English literature that can be brutally summarized in just five words the pity of it all Politicians are portrayed as Machiavellian, but simultaneously weak, generals are stupid, soldiers are brave helpless victims and war poets war poets are the latter day saints made flesh, Hart writes Hart largely eschews this crude sentimental approach, while admitting that the battle s death toll is higher than any sane individual would like to comprehend Hart argues that, while the Somme was certainly dreadful, the war itself This is certainly not a pleasant read but one that adds an entire dimension to what human beings can accept Although not the best book for a general description of the battle, the fact that it is nearly half first person accounts lends a personal human dimension to a battle where the overall human cost is too stagering to comprehend over 19,000 British dead in the first day, approximately 1.
5 million casualties overall for the four month battle After reading the simple personal expressions of the stoicism with which the men lived with death whether the unburied corpses of others or the likelihood of their own and simply went on,I should never complain about having a hard day again.
The Somme, a World War I battle that began in July, l916 and went on for four months, was designed to be a breakthrough on the western front by the British against well defended German positions, but it was a disaster and accomplished virtually nothing Nothing except the loss of seventy thousand lives and nearly half a million casualties on the British side.
Hart writes that the objective was to provide relief for the French, fighting on another front at Verdun, so it meant that the British commander, Douglas Haig, was under tremendous pressure to smash the Germans and bail out the French He has been much maligned, along with General Henry Rawlinson, for the needless sacrifice of thousands of young British lives Hart doesn t excuse them for a collective failure of generalship , one that kept ordering new attacks of the same kind that had just faile Between Verdun and the Somme, 1916 must be one of the worst years ever in the history of mankind Of course, we have WWII to look forward to The sheer brutality of this war is staggering and what was expected from these soldiers defies reason And for what This is the heart of man, the crown of creation, turned to brute beasts by his pride and lusts for power God have mercy.
A great work of history honest portrayal of the men and yet a fair assessment of the commanders Strips away the 100 years of myth that now surround the Western Front and especially the British losses at the Somme and elsewhere Only gave 3 stars because the denseness of the detail combined with poorly detailed maps in the Kindle version make some things hard to follow, but this is typical with detailed campaign histories in ebook form Also, the battle was so long that from a macro perspective, one doesn t learn much about how things went wrong or what could have been done better given many of the same mistakes and challenges hobbled Haig and his commanders from July all the way through the end of the year If you re not into all the detail, definitely skim this one but it s worth having examined.
Most starkly, Hart presents a compelling case for why there was simply no av This book is an account of one of the most god awful battles ever fought in history, beginning on a 25 mile stretch of the Western front, north of the Somme river, against the German army in World War I, on July 1, 1916 The British army had about 50,000 casualties on the first day 0f whom almost 20,000 were killed The battle dragged on into November, when the beginning of winter weather forced a cessation of new offensives The author, English historian Peter Hart, is a master story teller, and weaves extensive quotations from diaries, letters, and later accounts written by the men who were there and who survived, at least long enough to have written them Oral histories are also quoted Quotations come from not only the top generals, but even so from lesser officers and quite a number of enlisted men who were present on the The Somme is an oral history by an oral historian about one of the grimmest battles of World War I I didn t really like it, but I also didn t dislike it That is to say, I didn t loathe it with any particular intensity, and that s saying something, because I can get fairly riled up over inconsequential matters To begin, I will damn with faint praise The Somme was an allied offensive that began in July 1916 in the Somme River Valley of France To paraphrase William Goldman s script for A Bridge Too Far, the offensive was like every other offensive in military history designed to get the boys home by Christmas It did not succeed Author Peter Hart takes the position that the Somme of reality was not nearly so grim as the Somme of myth He argues that the soldiers weren t helpless victims who left their trenches in long lines only to get mowed down by Reading Peter Hart s The Battle of the Somme seemed, at times, as endless as the nearly 5 month long battle for small advances over a pulverized landscape But that s one of Hart s main points When it comes to war between modern nation states, battlefield geography is somewhat meaningless And the Somme, with its numerous battles for trench lines, shattered forests, flattened towns, was the British attempt to grind down the German Army And there was, incredibly, some success with this strategy Buried in this however is Hart s defense of General Haig, but I m not buying into that, since thousands were lost in poorly executed attacks That should fall on the planners, and Haig was at the top of that particular heap Still, Hart is fine writer, and the

Peter Hart is a British military historian.He has been an oral historian at Sound Archive of Imperial War Museum in London since 1981.He has written mainly on British participation in the First World War His books include The Somme, Jutland 1916, Bloody April on the air war in 1917, Passchendaele, Aces Falling on the air war in 1918 , 1918 A Very British Victory and Gallipoli Librarian Note Th